Top-rated cookie recipes worth saving
Six cookie recipes that hundreds or thousands of bakers rated 4.7 stars or more, from sugar cookies to chocolate chip, and how to keep them.
Updated
Cookies are baked for other people: a school sale, a tin for the neighbours, a plate in December. That is a bad moment for a recipe that spreads flat. These six were each rated highly by hundreds or thousands of bakers, and each can be saved to Spoonfile from its link.
Six top-rated cookie recipes
- Sugar CookiesPreppy Kitchen. 4.99 out of 5 from 4,988 ratings.Save to Spoonfile: Sugar Cookies
- Thick and Chewy Monster CookiesTastes Better from Scratch. 4.89 out of 5 from 1,111 ratings.Save to Spoonfile: Thick and Chewy Monster Cookies
- The Very Best Chocolate CookiesPinch of Yum. 4.8 out of 5 from 970 reviews.Save to Spoonfile: The Very Best Chocolate Cookies
- Christmas Sugar CookiesNatasha's Kitchen. 4.96 out of 5 from 620 ratings.Save to Spoonfile: Christmas Sugar Cookies
- Date CookiesFeel Good Foodie. 4.99 out of 5 from 619 ratings.Save to Spoonfile: Date Cookies
- Vegan Chocolate Chip CookiesCookie and Kate. 4.8 out of 5 from 472 reviews.Save to Spoonfile: Vegan Chocolate Chip Cookies
The links go to the recipe on its own site. Read the author's notes there before the first batch: they usually say whether the dough needs chilling and how to store the cookies.
How these were picked
Every recipe here had an average of 4.7 or more out of 5, from at least 400 ratings or reviews on its own site, when we read the pages on . The numbers are the ones each site publishes; they change as more people cook the recipe.
This is not a ranking of every recipe on the web. It is a short list of recipes that many cooks rated highly, from sites whose recipe pages Spoonfile can read from a link.
Save them to your own cookbook
A list like this is easy to lose in your bookmarks. Saved in Spoonfile, each recipe becomes a plain page of ingredients and steps that you can search, with the original page one tap away.
- Tap Save to Spoonfile under a recipe in the list. If you are not signed in, Spoonfile asks you to sign in first.
- The recipe's address is already filled in. Tap Import.
- Check the draft and tap Save. The link stays on the recipe as its source.
- Add a tag such as “cookies” so the recipes from this list stay together.
The copy is yours alone: nobody else sees it unless you share it. The steps in detail, and what happens when a page cannot be read, are in How to save just the recipe from a recipe website.
From the Spoonfile cookbook
We also keep a small cookbook of our own. You can read these recipes in full here, change the servings and the units, and save a copy to your recipes without importing anything.
The Spoonfile cookbook has the rest.
Bake a double batch
Under the ingredients of a saved recipe, Scale doubles or triples the amounts for a big batch, and Units shows them as Original, Metric or US.
For the cookies the family bakes every year, keep them next to these in a shared cookbook: How to share a family cookbook online.
More top-rated lists
- Top-rated chicken recipes worth saving
- Top-rated beef recipes worth saving
- Top-rated curry recipes worth saving
- Top-rated breakfast recipes worth saving
- Top-rated bread recipes worth saving
- Top-rated cake recipes worth saving
- Top-rated dinner recipes worth saving
- Top-rated baking recipes worth saving
- Top-rated soup recipes worth saving
Keep your recipes in one place
Enter your email address and we send you a link to sign in. No password to remember.
Free to use. No cap on the number of recipes.
